Is there any plugins/roadmaps for jira/crucible/fisheye to Teamcity integration?

I meant not the Teamcity to Altlassian, but Atlassian to teamcity. Atlassian provides powerful stack and it could be difficult to reject jira in favor of YouTrack, jetbrains doesn't have somethng similar to Fisheye/Crucible, so ordinal customer will be tightly coupled to atlassian products. For example now we choosing our build server and the main reason to chhose Bamboo is the ability to ingreate jira,crucibl, fisheye with bamboo. So, i can see in jira the issue is covered with build. Is it possible somehow with teamcity?

4 comments
Comment actions Permalink

We do not plan to implement plugin for the JIRA to show in which build the issue is fixed. But we have plugin in TeamCity for JIRA, which recognizes JIRA issues in commits. It is also possible to configure TeamCity to have a link from TC UI to Fisheye.

0
Comment actions Permalink

Hi, Pavel!
But why not? Teamcity is a great product and obviously beats bamboo/hudson/etc. Transparent integration to Atlassian environment will make it more attractive for customers, including our company. The same true for YouTrack - Crucible - Fisheye integration.

P.S. i wrongly marked this thread as a question, if it's possible to change the type, please do it.

regards, Alex

0
Comment actions Permalink

Well, to my personal opinion if you're using TeamCity most likely you do not need Fisheye at all. The most important functionality: diff view is available right in the TeamCity web UI. Moreover we support broader set of Version controls. Of course there is other functionality in Fisheye which can be useful sometimes, but again, I need such functionality very rarely, and I would prefer to use VCS specific tools. Also since I am working from IDE (IntelliJ IDEA) I have access to VCS specific information right in the IDE, and again. So to my opinion, if you use TeamCity + JetBrains IDE, there is no need to use Fisheye. Just for the case if you still need it, you can configure external change viewer in TeamCity (this way probably works with Crucible too): http://confluence.jetbrains.net/display/TCD6/External+Changes+Viewer

As for JIRA, maybe at some point we will provide such plugin. It's just a matter of priorities. Right now, we are more interested in increasing value of integration with our own tools.

0
Comment actions Permalink

Hi, Pavel.
I think this is based on the developement process chosen by team. So, my stories:
1) We have to review and verify all our production patches. We're happy to see all the changes related to the issue in JIRA. We can submit them in one click to create review. So if team is revewing code, this is very useful. This is not possible with teamcity.
2) Vcs specific tools require a cmd line skills, they are work slow on big repositories, etc. So they are not convenient when you need acces for different VCS and reporting. Fishyee allows much convenient sources filtering, for example filter concrete branch. (an sometimes i want filter file history by branch even in idea). As we reviewing changes, this is convenient fo us.

I can continue, but the main idea is - Teamcity isn't enough then you need to capture and process changes. So it's difficult to refuse Atlassian stack and difficult to integrate Teamcity into existing Atlassian environment.

regards, Alex

Message was edited by: Alexander Ashitkin

0

Please sign in to leave a comment.